Learning Medieval History Through Games: Useful, Misleading or Both?
That educational value comes from interaction. A game presents a model of the past, then asks the player to act inside it. The model may be accurate in some respects…
Medieval board games were not a single, clearly defined category. They included abstract strategy games, race games, dice games and pastimes based on capturing or blocking an opponent’s pieces. Some were played by elites, some by soldiers and travellers, and some appear in archaeological or literary evidence from a much wider social range. The surviving evidence is uneven, so modern players should distinguish between documented rules and informed reconstruction.
Games such as hnefatafl and nine men's morris are particularly suitable for contemporary play because their boards and basic principles can be recreated without specialist equipment. They also offer different kinds of challenge. Hnefatafl is a deliberately unbalanced battle game in which one side protects a king while the other surrounds him. Nine men's morris is a placement and movement game focused on forming lines, removing pieces and controlling space.
Trying these games is more rewarding when their historical limits are understood. A board found at an archaeological site does not automatically reveal the exact rules used by its players. In several cases, later descriptions, comparable games and the layout of the board must be considered together. That uncertainty is not a weakness. It gives players a useful reason to compare variants rather than treating one modern rule set as the definitive medieval version.
Hnefatafl belongs to the wider family of Scandinavian and northern European games often called tafl games. The Old Norse name is commonly associated with a board game involving a king, defenders and attackers. Related forms are known under names such as tablut and brandubh, although the boards, numbers of pieces and rules differ between variants. The evidence comes from sources including archaeological finds, written references and later recorded descriptions, and it does not establish one universal rulebook for every period or region.
The central idea is asymmetry. One player controls a king and a smaller group of defenders. The other controls a larger attacking force. The king usually begins near the centre and attempts to reach a designated escape square, often one of the board’s corners in modern reconstructions. The attackers normally begin around the edges and try to surround or capture the king. This creates a very different experience from chess-like games in which both sides have comparable forces and objectives.
A common reconstruction uses pieces that move any number of unobstructed squares along rows and columns, like a rook in chess. Ordinary pieces are captured when they are trapped between two opposing pieces on the same line. The king’s capture may require special treatment, sometimes involving four surrounding attackers or the board’s central or corner squares. Because these details vary by reconstruction, players should agree on them before starting.
For a first session, a smaller board is usually easier to understand than a large reconstruction with many pieces. The key tactical lesson is that the defender should not simply rush the king towards a corner. Open routes, protect vulnerable defenders and prevent the attackers from creating a complete ring. The attacker, by contrast, must balance pressure against the risk of leaving gaps that allow the king to escape.
Nine men's morris is a board game based on placing and moving counters on a pattern of connected lines. Each player has nine pieces. The familiar board contains three nested squares joined at their midpoints, creating a network of positions rather than a conventional grid. The game is generally divided into three stages: placing pieces, moving pieces and, in many rulesets, allowing a player with only three pieces to move to any vacant position.
During the placement stage, players take turns putting one piece on an empty point. Forming a row of three pieces along a marked line creates a mill. The player who forms a mill normally removes one opposing piece, subject to restrictions that often prevent removing a piece already in a mill unless all opposing pieces are protected in that way.
Once all pieces have been placed, players move one piece at a time to an adjacent vacant point. The objective is to form additional mills, reduce the opponent’s material and restrict legal movement. Some rulesets allow a player reduced to three pieces to “fly”, meaning that a piece may move to any vacant point. Other modern rules omit or modify this rule, so it should be stated before play begins.
The game rewards more than the immediate creation of a line. A strong move may create a threat that cannot be answered, occupy a junction needed for movement or prepare a repeated sequence in which a piece leaves and reforms a mill. Beginners often focus on completing one mill while overlooking the opponent’s ability to build a blocking structure. Counting empty points and identifying escape routes are as important as spotting a possible row of three.
Hnefatafl and nine men's morris are only two examples. Medieval gaming culture also included several families of games with different origins and rule traditions.
These games illustrate a broad principle: medieval players did not require a single standard model of strategy. Some games emphasised territorial restriction, others movement and chance, and others the tension created by unequal objectives. A mixed evening can therefore offer more historical and practical variety than a session devoted only to a familiar chessboard.
Reconstructing medieval games requires care because the evidence usually preserves objects better than instructions. Boards may be scratched into stone, wood or other surfaces, while the original pieces may be lost. A literary reference may name a game without explaining its moves. An illustration can show people playing but may not reveal the complete setup. Later rulebooks can preserve older traditions, but they may also describe changes introduced after the medieval period.
For this reason, an educational game session should label its materials honestly. Terms such as “historical reconstruction”, “modern adaptation” and “inspired by archaeological evidence” are more accurate than claiming that a particular set reproduces an entire medieval tradition. Useful reference points include archaeological reports, editions of medieval literature, museum catalogues and scholarly studies of historical games. Where a ruleset draws on several sources, the organiser can briefly explain that it is a reconstruction rather than a directly preserved rulebook.
Board geometry also deserves attention. A modern printed board may use regular lines and clearly marked points, while a historical board could be uneven, incomplete or adapted to the available surface. This does not prevent play, but it reminds players that the material experience of the original game may have differed from using a manufactured set.
A successful session needs simple equipment and clear expectations. Most games can be played with a cloth or wooden board, counters and a short rules sheet. Coins, stones or coloured tokens can substitute for purpose-made pieces, provided that the two sides are easy to distinguish and the pieces do not roll away.
A practical format for a group is:
For families, nine men's morris is often easier to introduce because its board is visually clear and the placement phase gives new players time to learn. Hnefatafl can suit older children and adults who enjoy spatial planning, provided the king’s objective and capture rules are explained with a diagram or sample position. A mixed-age group can pair a more experienced player with a beginner without turning the game into a competition decided entirely by explanation.
Keep the historical discussion separate from unsupported storytelling. It is reasonable to explain that games have been found or described in particular contexts when the source supports that claim. It is not reasonable to invent a scene about who played a specific board, what they thought or how often a game was used. The game itself provides enough material for discussion through its rules, asymmetry and design.
Players may also encounter drawn or repetitive positions. Not every historical reconstruction gives a complete solution. A modern group can agree to declare a draw after a repeated position or after both players acknowledge that no meaningful progress is being made. The important point is to state the convention before the game starts.
| Game | Main objective | Typical challenge | Best use in a group |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hnefatafl | The king escapes while attackers try to capture or surround him | Managing unequal forces and open routes | Longer strategy sessions with role changes |
| Nine men's morris | Form mills, remove opposing pieces and restrict movement | Planning threats while preserving mobility | Family introductions and short repeated games |
| Alquerque | Capture opposing pieces through movement and jumps | Reading sequences of forced captures | Players who enjoy tactical exchanges |
| Historical chess reconstruction | Checkmate or the objective defined by the selected period rules | Learning how older piece movements differ from modern chess | Advanced comparison of rule changes |
This comparison is a starting point rather than a ranking. The most suitable game depends on the group’s age, attention span and interest in historical reconstruction. A session can also rotate games so that players experience different ideas of strategy instead of assuming that every board game rewards the same type of thinking.
“Viking chess” is a modern popular label often used for hnefatafl and related tafl games. It can be useful for recognition, but it should not imply that the game followed one universally fixed rule set or that it was identical to modern chess.
Yes. Draw the board with its connected lines and use nine counters of one colour for each player. The pieces only need to be distinct and small enough to fit clearly on each point.
Nine men's morris is often the simplest starting point because the board, pieces and first objective are easy to demonstrate. A short practice game can introduce mills before players learn the movement stage.
Rules were not always written down, boards can be incomplete and later sources may preserve changed traditions. Reconstructions therefore combine different types of evidence and should identify the assumptions they make.
Use a named reconstruction or clearly documented ruleset, explain what is known and uncertain, avoid invented stories and record any house rules. This keeps the activity enjoyable while respecting the limits of the evidence.